Skip to main content

Book review of The Defence of Duffer's Drift

Author.

(a)    Credentials. The author of this book is Major General Sir Ernest Dunlop Swinton, KBE, CB, DSO, RE. He was born on 21st October, 1868. He is a very popular British Army officer and successful military writer. He is been regarded as the man responsible for the adoption of tank in First World War. He also defined no-man’s land.

(b)   Other Works. He has written many books such as his autobiography known as Over My shoulder and twenty years after the battlefields of 1914-1918. Then and now.


Theme.

(c)    Genre. The Defence of duffer’s drift is a fiction book but after reading it you will wish that it was non-fiction.
(d)   Treatment of subject. The author has treated the subject in matured way where he is successful to maintain the interest of the readers.
(e)   Approach. Ernest has maintained a practical approach which is essential for military leaders of the future.
(f)     Characterization. Well there is only one character in the whole book and that is the author himself.
(g)    Language and style. Language is kept very simple for the understanding purpose and with the intention to make readers understand the style in which author has written is impressive.
(h)   Moral. The moral at the end are twenty two lessons for military leaders which they can use in active service.



Production Value.
(a)    Cover Binding. The book printed by United Service Magazine is of hard cover and ensures that you cannot spoil the book even you try as hard as possible.
(b)   Paper. The quality of paper is excellent, and leaves a good impression on the readers.
(c)    Printing. The book printed by United Service Magazine is magnificent. The size of the book is kept medium as military leaders can carry it with ease.
(d)   Maps. One military map of duffer’s drift is used in the book. Throughout the book the same map is used and no other image is there. The map is very helpful to understand the crisis which author is trying to explain.
(e)   Cost. In India the book cost only Rs. 85/-

Verdict.
(a)    Target Audience. The book targets the military intellectual and the young military leaders who are going to be company commanders in their army.
(b)   Value of work. I am no one to comment on value of work, as this work is hundred years old and still can be find in central library. Very important lessons derived out only for the military leaders.

Conclusion.
As the book is written for the young military leaders, it is like a guide for them. Twenty two lessons which seems less are very handy to lead troops in the battle. The only thing is that the book is very old, and doesn’t explain limited war tactics. It is a perfect book for conventional warfare.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Battle of Longewala

After drifting for approximately thousand kilometers from Alwar, I have reached Longewala. This place romanticizes me allot. The battle of Longewala a legend in itself. It is located at 120 kms from city of Jaisalmer. Only way to reach this place is boulevard and if you are tourist then you have to hire a cab. Longewala is prevalent because of the illustrious skirmish tussled between India and Pakistan in 1971. The clash of Longewala is all about how hundred odd men clogged and overwhelmed approximately 2000 Pakistani legionnaires. This battle was all about the audacity, impetus, chauvinism and drive to prizefight exhibited by those eighty Indian warriors. This scuffle is one of my favorite scuffles, and whenever I come to this place, my mind start envisaging how horde of men repudiated the destiny. During the Indo-Pak war of 1971, A-Coy of 23 Punjab had taken up the defences at Longewala. The A-Coy company commander was Major Kuldeep Singh Chandpuri later on emer...

IS THIS TRUTH OR ANOTHER COMEDY BY PAKISTAN ARMY????

Kashmir War 1947 - 49 By November 1947 Auchinleck, Supreme Commander based in New Delhi, being convinced that Indian Cabinet was seeking to destroy and undo Pakistan by economic and military means, was forced to resign. As the build-up of Indian forces in Jammu and Kashmir continued, Pakistan Army units were being hurriedly organized and equipped without any base for manufacture of ammunition, signal stores, equipment or vehicles. Simultaneously, Pakistan National Guards were raised from ex-servicemen and other volunteers along border areas to provide a second line of defence. By February 1948 Indian build up in Jammu and Kashmir reached five brigades plus, under two full-fledged division Headquarters. Our 101 Brigade, commanded by Brigadier Akbar Khan was rushed into the critical front to forestall and halt the Indian offensive along Uri-Muzaffarabad axis. In April 1948, Commander-in-Chief Pakistan Army appreciating the threats in the north along Muzaffarabad-Kohala...

INDIAN AIR FORCE ADOPTS 'GO GREEN TREND'

Mission Accomplishment Paramount Even as IAF Initiates ODS Alternatives in Weapon Systems The Indian Air Force (IAF) is adopting a multi-pronged strategy to combat ozone depletion including limiting the use of Halon to mission critical uses, tighter control laws and incorporating accountability towards phase-out of ODS (Ozone Depleting Substances) said Air Chief Marshal PV Naik while delivering the inaugural address at the two-day International Workshop on ‘Benefits of ODS Phase-out in Defence Forces’ organized by Centre for Air Power Studies (CAPS), today. Air Chief Marshal P.V. NAIK While highlighting initiatives taken by the IAF, and encouraging alternatives, the Air Chief however, clarified, “Mission accomplishment remains paramount for the Armed Forces. Substituting an ODS would only be done, if it doesn’t impinge on operational effectiveness of the system in question.” For new weapon systems in the pipeline, inclusion of a clause in RFPs for provision of alter...